Showing posts with label Once Upon A Time. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Once Upon A Time. Show all posts

Friday, May 16, 2014

The Geek Roundup Season Finales: Once Upon a Time, Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D., Grimm

I'm a bit behind on thoughts and reviews I planned, so I'm going to do this lot in one batch before the memory fades:


Remember when you thought you left the gas on? This is worse.

Once Upon a Time: "There's No Place Like Home";  Very Good.  Exits the season with a timey-wimey episode that involves Emma and Hook going into the Pillar of Fire vortex triggered by Zelena's death.(Note to Storybrook residents: when the bad guy or girl you've just defeated makes a construct for their evil scheme  destroy it utterly before going to celebrate at Granny's).

It could have been tedious or rife with bad cliches, but it was all well done, espcially seeing Hook jealous of his past self who also has a thing for Emma.   Robert Carlyle is in good form as old Rumple( Emma re Hook:"You've sorta buried the hatchet." Rumple: "Yes, but why isn't it in his head?"), and it's a relief it takes less time than usual in timey-wimey stories to convince him they're from the future.  Given magic is a reality that makes sense, but writers of genre shows often forget that.(Both Star Trek Voyager and Next Generation had bright spots of awareness).    Rumple and Belle finally marry and I hope I was seeing Rumple replace the fake dagger he tricked Belle with(Bad Rumple!) with the real one so their marriage mostly starts out on the right foot.

It sucks that the woman Emma and Hook rescue from the Regina the Evil Queen turns out to be Regina the pseudo-reformed antihero's boyfriend's formerly dead wife, but this is a chance for the character to grow.   It will be beyond tedious if the writers try to "make her evil" once again.  I suspect Marion is doomed anyway.  Tink may be a rogue fairy, but my impression is the fairy dust itself never lies.  So unless it works only in one direction, Robin and Regina are "meant for each other" in the OUAT universe.  Of course in real life everyone has multiple people that could make long term happy relationships.  It would be a refreshing break for the writers to incorporate this is the OUAT universe:  "Yes, Regina, I feel you're my soul mate, but I love Marion too and, well, she got here first."

I've no clue who this Frosty/Frozen/Snow Queen person is at the end, though fandom appears to be deeply impressed.  Love the idea, Snow Queen, with maybe a bit of Queen Jadis (A blizzard in June?  Strange weather in Storybrooke!), but I'm less impressed with the cheezy blue and sequined dress.  Come on, snow/ice theme villains have a meme that works: white, ice, sparkle.  That's a crystal sparkle not glittery.  Any variation had better be knock your eyes out awesome to pull off.  This just made me think "what"?

Boring place holder while I hunt down the episode for a screenie.


Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.(last time I type it with periods) first season finale, "Beginning of the End": Out-fracking-satnding.  So much awesome in it I know I need to watch it again for bits I missed.  Highlights include May kicking Ward's ass,  Nick Fury back from the grave,   Deathlock getting free and a quintessential Joss Whedon fake-out playing with our expectations: when the highly modified and motivated Garrett turns out not be be dead and drags himself out of his metal box into the supper soldier machine to modify himself into a near invincible killing machine, he has only enough time to chew the scenery a bit before Coulson blows him away.  Absolutely brilliant.

Also, they seem to be distancing themselves from the hokey HYDRA meme, which is fine by me. They imply Garrett was a rogue, rogue agent, but whatever.  He's just random  atomic particles now.

Aww...it looks so sweet.  You know it can't last.

Grimm: "Blond Ambition"; Very Good.  Joining a line of genre shows(okay, oneish) with not so perfect weddings. The good news is neither Monroe or Rosalee  were visited by a time traveling version of themselves warning them to break off the marriage to save the person they love[Buffy reference].   Neither does Rosalee burst into song.   But what does happen is Adalind goes thru with the de-Grimming program for Nick.  Her "reasons" don't even make sense--"get back at " Nick?  His mum who saved her and her baby.  And  there's no guarantee she'll get her kid back after this.  In fact all she's done is burn bridges with all the people who had some sympathy for her.  It's the only weak bit in this episode:  is Adalind really that stupid and gullible? She must be the charms of the deliciously evil Alex Denisof, who does villain very, very well.  Now, when he's on the screen, I almost never think about that "Rogue Demon Hunter" .

Truble leaps into awesome form, heroically trying to save Nick but, alas, is too late.  It doesn't help when she crashes the wedding and the guests see her as a Grimm and go nuts and break the green potion stuff that would have saved Nick's Grimmness.  I predict next season there will be lots and lots and lots of research at the Magic Box, er, Rosalee's shop.

We're left with a cliff hanger on weather Sean will survive being shot--which almost guarantees he will. Come on, his Hexenbiest DNA has to count for something.  But then that didn't help Adalind's mother and she was just cut with glass.

I'm personally pleased Wu is being set up to come into the Masquerade...and look forward to the royal bitching out he'll give everyone for letting him think he was going crazy.  Except for maybe Hank, they all deserve it.

All is all an enjoyable ep, and solid setup for the next season. 

These three make up for the mixed ending of "The Tomorrow People", which was a victim of that Dark and Sinister Force in the Universe known as their own writers.  Never able to break out of their After School special plotting, they doomed the show, even though the ending hints at a future.  Maybe they think they'll be picked up by Syfy.  The show and actors may deserve a second chance, but the writers need to have that very honest dicussion about their flaws and limits that George Lucas never got when he made "Phantom Menace".

A more worthy candidate for Syfy that was also cancelled in "Almost Human".  Great show, great chemistry, but went out with a whimper on their last episode.  Of course, since Fox played the eps out of order in what fandom understandably suspects was an effort to sabotage the show,  we don't know if that was supposed to be the "last" episode.  I'm willing to give TTP another chance is they find a home, but if there's a choice between TTP and Almost Human is the higher quality show.

Alas, now veiwing will be dry a while as I wait for "Sleepy Hollow", "Doctor Who", and "Walking Dead" to return.  Though there still is "Continuum" to keep me company.  Perhaps now I'll take the time to explore another well talked about show I simply didn't have time for:

"Supernatural"?   "Barely Human"?  Or actually check out "True Blood" or "Game of Thrones"?

We'll see.



Monday, January 7, 2013

Once Upon a Time: The Cricket Game Review

I always know when people lie...
but the writers forgot so this might get messy...


I've been enjoying Once Upon a Time since I discovered a reference to it via my interest in Fables.

Initially I was wroth..
."Who are these people what dare to make a TV series about Fairytale Characters in the Real World and not adapt Fables to the screen?  Grr...I suspect dishonorable motives!"
Which might still be true on the part of the executives, but I've been won over by the producers and writers who swear up and down they knew nothing of Willingham's work.  I could believe this--I've written things for years cloistered from the fan community.  However I reserve judgement about the executives who I have a hard time believing would take a chance on a fantasy property without knowing there is a fanbase for this theme AND knowing who built it.  So thank you Willingham for making Once Upon A Time possible as a TV series.

SPOILERS.

The series centers on character from well known fairytales: Snow White, The Evil Queen(Regina), Red Ridding Hood, Rumpelstiltskin, Beauty(Belle), Prince Charming and others.  Because Regina has never gotten over Snow White beating her out  in the Fairytale Fairest of Them All Competition--plus Snow accidentally getting Regina's BF killed when she was a kid, oops--Regina finally has her revenge by destroying the Homelands(Willingham's phraseology) and sending everyone to A World Without Magic aka a World with No Happy Endings, aka a picturesque  fictitious town on the east coast called  Storybrook.  It's not too miserable(Regina has to live there), except no one knows who they are with the exception of Regina, and we later find Rumpelstiltskin(Mr. Gold). Everyone happily lives as muggles, except Henry, Regina's adopted son who knows the Truth and sets out to find his real mum, Emma Swan,  a bailbond/bounty hunter who has the ability to know when someone is lying.  Henry is also convinced she is the Hero who will save the town.  This forms the story arc of the first series which is well done.  I eagerly looked forward to the second Season.

The second season started out solid, picking up after everyone remembers who they are.  Karma's a bitch, chickens come home to roost, and new developments arise.  Then the series takes a risk with Regina pulling an Angel , seeking redemption.  This can be tedious in the hands of the best writers.  Unwatchable in the hands of incompetent or naive writers.  Even Joss Whedon and Co, writing Angel and Buffy in my opinion averaged okay with the redemption themes.   And Regina doesn't have Angel's excuse of actually being a different person(Angelus) from the one who did all those horrid things.

There is a way to deal with this, properly deal with it: Regina can say she wants to be Good, but she has to allow people will suspect her motives.  Furthermore, she must allow some people will take years before they believe it, and, even if it's true, some people will NEVER forgive her.  And she has to have the sober humility to accept that they have a right to do that and she will have to live with it for the rest of her life.

This is how it is is reality, but is almost never done in TV.   Writers, producers or someone in the process is uncomfortable with Good characters failing to forgive all but the worst monsters. Hollywood culture has some very wooly thinking going on.  Or perhaps they're uncomfortable with hard truths in a contemporary setting.  I saw this in Buffy the year(Fifth Season) they pulled out of their asses that 'the Slayer never kills humans'.

Bollox.  (Warning fan mini rant ahead)

Patrice, the assassin from the Order of Taraka was killed in the fracas with Kendra the Slayer.

Buffy kicked numerous Knights of Byzantium of the top of the caravan, and they were nominally good guys!  What do you think is going to happen to someone falling off the top of a moving caravan, weighed down with armor, with no helmet?  The Slayer never kills humans except accidentally?  Didn't they give Faith a ton of grief about that?   And it's completely contradicted by the story of Sonnenblume, the slayer who operated during Nazi Germany.  The Slayer only kills humans if they're Nazis?

The probable real reason 'the Slayer never kills humans' bollox was invented is the culture was uncomfortable writing stories where a  contemporary young woman could use lethal force on humans and not be accountable by the legal system.  This wouldn't have been a problem in a historical setting.  It also wouldn't have been a problem if the hero was a young man.   Human's were turned into mincemeat all the time in Highlander..in the modern world.   It was like some executive was trying to reframe our experience of Buffy, make the powerful young woman culturally "safer".

These are the same people(in the industry generally, not the Buffy producers) who I'm now to trust with an emotionally believable redemption of the Evil Queen, when so far all they've given us is, "I want to be good to impress Henry."  Excuse me while I reserve judgment.

Back to this Once Upon a Time episode...I don't suspect cowardly executive meddling so much as sloppy writing.  Everything was going okay...the redemption theme was handled unevenly(close ups of hurt Regina...please.  She was the EVIL Queen.  Grin and bear it or leave gracefully, woman)..and now someone has handed the writers the idiot ball...

MORE SPOILERS

I'll try to be brief.  There was a murder.  The viewer knows it's Cora, Regina's Mommy Dearest, shaping up to be this season's Big Bad.  Because Cora is a twisted bitch, she kills disguised as Regina hoping to frame her and drive her back into mummy's arms.   So far , fine.  When Regina is questioned by the sheriff, Emma, who has the ability to know when someone is lying.  But Emma doesn't use this talent, instead relying on Regina's reactions, which are spot on for an innocent person.

But that's not the point.  Regina is on social "probation"; considering her past, it is unreasonable to rely on her reactions which could be faked.   So just using Emma's lie detector superpower, we can KNOW Regina is innocent and everything else is a frame.   But the writers forgot EMMA KNOWS WHEN PEOPLE ARE LYING.  It's on her abc page people:

http://beta.abc.go.com/shows/once-upon-a-time/bios/emma-swan

Emma Swan

Played by Jennifer Morrison

Emma 101
- Daughter of Snow White and Prince Charming

- Biological mother of Henry

- Broke The Dark Curse

- Skeptical; knows when people lie
This was  a plot point early in season two between Emma and Hook.  Even AV Club..whose views I don't always agree with, but are generally astute observers... let this slide in their review:

Ruby tells Emma about the day before and Regina is brought into custody, but while Snow and Charming are certain of Regina’s guilt, Emma believes her when she says she’s innocent. Surely there’s some kind of truth spell they could use on Regina to find out if she’s lying, but magic is only used when it’s convenient on this show.
Italics mine.  They don't need a truth spell.  They have Emma, who's inherent power is knowing if someone's lying.  The writers or production crew got inexcusably sloppy.  And I will not spin some fanwank benefit of the doubt rubbish to help them save face.

I was holding out to the end of the EP, hoping for a twist, but only more idiot balls:  Regina reactively defends herself against a binding spell, and that's PROOF she's not serious about quitting magic.  Uh huh.  And I suppose picking up a bottle in a bar brawl is PROOF you've been drinking.  Okay, not the best metaphor(a person quitting drinking is unlikely to be in a bar)... but what was she supposed to do?  She can't turn off two decades of magical combat training overnight.

Sloppy writing can be the sign of impending doom.  If someone isn't watching continuity, someone isn't giving the show the resources it needs to succeed.  I will still watch it and hope for the best, but do so with my expectations lowered.